Talk:AIF/@comment-24171828-20140830110302/@comment-10905876-20140831164523

Boston vs Mercury I think Mercury would win, she's bigger and more heavily armed, but still very fast.

Relentless would probably win against the cruisers, unless the cruisers managed to make torpedo runs on her.

Defiant vs Surcouf, while the Defiant is a powerfully armed ship for her size, she is still not very durable on account of her armor. Her best chance would be to force Surcouf to submerge and then use her ASW torpedoes. But in a surface action Surcouf wins easily due to her heavy guns.